Real Law Society Editorial Material
Prepared by the Real Law Society. Commentary and apparatus only; it carries no authority of its own.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Under linked (a), signature authenticity and authority are admitted unless specifically denied in the pleadings. A specific denial places the validity burden on the person asserting validity, but a presumption of authenticity and authority ordinarily remains. The stated exception concerns an action enforcing the purported signer's liability when that signer is dead or incompetent at trial of validity. Denial and removal of the presumption are not the same event.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. For an undisclosed-principal claim described in (a), the plaintiff must establish liability as a represented person under § 3-402(a). This cross-reference is not a separate review of agency or representative-signature law.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Under (b), signatures must be admitted or proved and (a) satisfied. A plaintiff producing the instrument must also prove entitlement to enforce under § 3-301; possession alone is not the stated test. The defendant may prove a defense or claim in recoupment. The lost-instrument route requires separate attention to § 3-309 and its proof conditions.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Once a defense or recoupment claim is proved, payment remains subject to it except to the extent the plaintiff proves holder-in-due-course rights not subject to that defense or claim. This does not say that every proved defense disappears upon showing protected rights. The nature of the particular defense and the applicable limits still matter.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Virginia § 8.3A-308, inspected on 2026-10-17, uses incapacitated in the signer exception where the LII page uses incompetent. It retains the distinct signature, enforcement-entitlement and proved-defense requirements. This narrow textual comparison does not decide a pleading, capacity issue or evidentiary dispute.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. The unverified 1990 edition label and the assertion that this summary structures every instrument action are removed. Exact edition, operative law and case-specific proof remain unverified. No pleading template, burden-of-production case survey or judgment prediction is supplied.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Additional references checked 2026-10-17: LII § 3-305; Virginia § 8.3A-308. The principal LII reference is linked below. Live pages may change after the check date.
