Real Law Society Editorial Material
Prepared by the Real Law Society. Commentary and apparatus only; it carries no authority of its own.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. In linked (a)(1), promised performance supplies value only to the extent performed. Paragraph (2) includes security interests and other liens in the instrument but excludes liens obtained through judicial proceedings. Paragraph (3) includes taking as payment of, or security for, an antecedent claim against any person, whether due or not; discharge of an existing debt is not the sole route.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Paragraph (4) addresses exchange for a negotiable instrument. Paragraph (5) addresses an irrevocable obligation incurred to a third party by the taker. These are distinct routes, not a general rule that any promise or any cash purchase automatically establishes every protected status.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Subsection (b) uses the consideration standard sufficient for a simple contract. It gives a drawer or maker a defense when issuance lacks consideration, and an issuer a defense to the extent promised performance is due but unperformed. Issuance for value under (a) also constitutes issuance for consideration. That statement does not make every unperformed promise value.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Value is an element of a holder's own status under § 3-302. The separate § 3-203(b) can vest a transferor's enforcement rights, including holder-in-due-course rights, subject to its fraud/illegality qualification. The former categorical suggestion that lack of value defeats every possible claim to such rights was too broad. Neither route alone establishes enforcement entitlement or defeats every defense.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Virginia § 8.3A-303, inspected on 2026-10-17, contains the same five value routes and separate consideration/performance provisions. This is not a finding that any payment, lien, claim or performance has been proved in a particular transaction.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. The unverified 1990 edition label is removed. Exact edition, state applicability and operative dates remain pending. Value, consideration, enforcement status and defenses must not be collapsed into a single conclusion.
Editorial commentary — not part of the primary text.
Editorial note. Additional references checked 2026-10-17: LII § 3-203; Virginia § 8.3A-303. The principal LII reference is linked below. Live pages may change after the check date.
