Contents▾
Introduction
In the previous chapter, we examined reversions and remainders, the two future interests that most commonly follow naturally terminating estates such as life estates.
This chapter introduces a different concept.
Rather than following an estate that is certain to end—such as a life estate—a defeasible fee is a fee simple estate that may end if a specified event occurs. (Legal Information Institute)
This distinction is important.
A fee simple absolute continues indefinitely unless voluntarily conveyed or otherwise terminated by law. A defeasible fee, however, is created with an express limitation that may alter ownership in the future. The condition exists from the moment the property is conveyed and determines whether the estate will continue or terminate. (Legal Information Institute)
What Is a Defeasible Fee?
A defeasible fee is a present fee simple estate that is subject to a condition established when the conveyance is made.
The holder possesses a fee simple estate immediately, but that estate may terminate if the stated condition occurs. Because the estate can be defeated by a future event, it is known as a defeasible fee. (Legal Information Institute)
Unlike a life estate, which is measured by the passage of time, a defeasible fee is measured by the occurrence—or nonoccurrence—of a specified event. (Legal Information Institute)
This distinction may be summarized as follows:
- Fee Simple Absolute: No built-in condition; continues indefinitely; no accompanying future interest based on a condition.
- Defeasible Fee: Subject to an express condition; may terminate upon the occurrence of a specified event; accompanied by a future interest tied to the condition.
The legal consequences depend upon both the language used in the conveyance and who holds the future interest.
Why Defeasible Fees Exist
Defeasible fees allow property owners to encourage or preserve particular uses of land while still transferring a present ownership interest.
Historically and today, defeasible fees are commonly used for:
- charitable gifts;
- educational institutions;
- churches and religious organizations;
- parks and recreational land;
- conservation purposes;
- municipal land grants; and
- family transfers accompanied by continuing conditions.
For example, a grantor may wish to ensure that land continues to be used as a public park or school while providing that ownership changes if that purpose is abandoned.
Rather than relying solely on contractual promises, a defeasible fee incorporates the condition directly into the estate itself. (Legal Information Institute)
Fee Simple Determinable
A fee simple determinable is a fee simple estate that automatically terminates when a stated condition occurs.
It is created using durational language, indicating that ownership continues only while a specified circumstance exists. (Legal Information Institute)
Common phrases include:
- "so long as"
- "while"
- "during"
- "until"
- "as long as"
When the condition is violated, the estate ends automatically, and ownership immediately returns to the grantor.
The accompanying future interest is called a possibility of reverter. (Legal Information Institute)
Example
“O conveys Blackacre to A so long as the land is used as a public park.”
- Present Estate: A — Fee Simple Determinable.
- Future Interest: O — Possibility of Reverter.
If the property ceases to be used as a public park, A's estate ends automatically, and ownership immediately reverts to O.
Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent
A fee simple subject to condition subsequent is also a defeasible fee, but it differs in one crucial respect.
The estate does not terminate automatically when the stated condition occurs.
Instead, the grantor retains the option to reclaim the property by exercising a right of entry, sometimes called a power of termination. (Legal Information Institute)
This estate is commonly created using conditional language, such as:
- "provided that"
- "on condition that"
- "but if"
Example
“O conveys Blackacre to A, but if the land ceases to be used as a school, O may re-enter and reclaim the property.”
- Present Estate: A — Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent.
- Future Interest: O — Right of Entry (Power of Termination).
Unlike a fee simple determinable, ownership remains with A until O affirmatively exercises the retained right. Simply violating the condition does not automatically transfer possession. (Legal Information Institute)
Fee Simple Subject to an Executory Limitation
The third principal defeasible fee is the fee simple subject to an executory limitation.
Like a fee simple determinable, it ends automatically upon the occurrence of the specified event.
Unlike the previous two estates, however, the property does not return to the grantor.
Instead, ownership automatically passes to a third party designated in the original conveyance.
The corresponding future interest is an executory interest. (Legal Information Institute)
Example
“O conveys Blackacre to A so long as the land is used as a church, then to B.”
- Present Estate: A — Fee Simple Subject to an Executory Limitation.
- Future Interest: B — Executory Interest.
If the property ceases to be used as a church, A's estate automatically terminates, and B immediately acquires possession.
Unlike a possibility of reverter or a right of entry, the future interest belongs to someone other than the grantor. (Legal Information Institute)
Comparing the Three Defeasible Fees
This comparison illustrates that similar wording can produce different legal consequences depending upon both the language of the conveyance and the destination of the future interest. (Legal Information Institute)
| Estate | Creating Language | How Ownership Ends | Future Interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fee Simple Determinable | Durational language | Automatically returns to the grantor | Possibility of reverter |
| Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent | Conditional language | Grantor must affirmatively act to reclaim the property | Right of entry (power of termination) |
| Fee Simple Subject to an Executory Limitation | Durational or conditional language directing property to a third party | Automatically transfers to that third party | Executory interest |
Reading Conveyancing Language
One of the most valuable skills in property law is learning to identify the estate created by the language of the conveyance.
When analyzing any conveyance, ask three questions:
- What present estate has been created?
- What event may alter that estate?
- Who holds the future interest if the condition occurs?
These questions provide a reliable framework for identifying defeasible fees.
Practical Applications
Defeasible fees continue to appear in modern real estate transactions and institutional land transfers.
Common examples include:
- land donated for parks or recreational facilities;
- property conveyed to schools or universities;
- church property subject to continuing religious use;
- municipal land grants;
- conservation and preservation projects; and
- charitable gifts imposing continuing use restrictions.
Because these estates affect ownership itself—not merely contractual obligations—they are significant in title examination, deed drafting, trust administration, and litigation involving real property.
Common Misconceptions
"Every Condition Creates a Defeasible Fee"
Not necessarily. Many deeds contain promises, covenants, or contractual obligations that do not create defeasible estates.
Whether a defeasible fee exists depends upon the language of the conveyance and the grantor's manifested intent. Courts generally interpret deeds according to established principles of conveyancing and applicable state law. (Legal Information Institute)
"Automatic Termination and a Right to Re-Enter Are the Same"
They are not. A fee simple determinable ends automatically when the triggering condition occurs. A fee simple subject to condition subsequent continues until the grantor elects to enforce the retained right of entry. These are distinct legal consequences with important practical implications. (Legal Information Institute)
"All Defeasible Fees Return the Property to the Grantor"
Incorrect. Only the fee simple determinable and the fee simple subject to condition subsequent involve future interests retained by the grantor. A fee simple subject to an executory limitation automatically transfers ownership to a designated third party. (Legal Information Institute)
Key Takeaways
- A defeasible fee is a fee simple estate that may terminate upon the occurrence of a specified condition. (Legal Information Institute)
- A fee simple determinable ends automatically upon violation of a durational condition and is accompanied by a possibility of reverter. (Legal Information Institute)
- A fee simple subject to condition subsequent does not end automatically; the grantor must exercise a right of entry to reclaim the property. (Legal Information Institute)
- A fee simple subject to an executory limitation automatically transfers ownership to a third party holding an executory interest. (Legal Information Institute)
- The wording of the conveyance is critical because different language creates different estates and different future interests.
- Properly identifying both the present estate and the accompanying future interest is essential in deed interpretation, title examination, estate planning, and property litigation.
Continue Your Reading
Next Chapter — Concurrent Ownership
The next chapter examines concurrent ownership, the body of law governing situations in which two or more persons hold present ownership interests in the same parcel of land. It introduces tenancy in common, joint tenancy, tenancy by the entirety, and related doctrines governing survivorship, partition, and the rights and duties of co-owners.